Adventures in Sleep Training

Sleep training has been written about a thousand times over by bloggers far more qualified than I am. But everyone has a unique experience with the beast we call baby sleep, and I thought I’d weigh in. I’ll cover bedtime first, and naps in a few days.
There are so many options when it comes to getting your baby to sleep better. There are the gentle, ‘no-cry’ methods (like The No-Cry Sleep Solution), methods that involve extinction (letting the baby cry until they fall asleep), and methods in the middle, that involve crying-it-out (CIO) with periodic checks. Knowing Miss K’s personality, and having tried a few no-cry solutions in the past, we decided to go with a method recommended by our naturopath (based on Ferber).

What does this look like? For us, a little something like this:

1. Bedtime routine (pyjamas, story, prayers, nursing)
2. Put her down awake, but drowsy
3. Turn on the Sleep Sheep, close her door, and bolt down the stairs like a bat out of hell.
4. When the crying starts (because it will, inevitably, start), set the timer for 5 minutes, and wait.
At this point, I grabbed a new cinnamon roll recipe, and barricaded myself in the kitchen where I couldn’t hear her crying.
5. J checked on her at the 5 minute mark, shushed and patted her for about a minute, then left. When the crying started again, we set the timer for 7 minutes.
At this point, it was time to knead the cinnamon roll dough.
6. J checked at 7 minutes, patted and shushed her for a minute, then came back downstairs to sample the ‘goo’ for the bottom of the cinnamon roll pan.

We had planned to check in another 10 minutes, but K had put herself to sleep at that point. 29 minutes from start to sleep, and it was tough, but doable. Plus, we had cinnamon rolls rising in the fridge for the next morning.

The second night was much the same as the first. Bedtime rolled around, we carried out our routine and put her down awake. She cried for 7 minutes, then just as I got up to check, she fell asleep. She woke at 2, 6, and was up at 8:30 for the day. I’ve uttered the words “Is this real life?” more times than I care to admit over the last few days.

Day three was even quicker; she whimpered briefly, then got quiet. Up at 4 for a feed, then at 7 for the day.

TL;DR? Bedtime routine, put baby down awake, when the crying starts, wait five minutes. Pat and shush for 30 seconds to 1 minute, then leave. Crying starts – wait 7 minutes. Pat and shush again. Crying starts? Wait 10 minutes. Pat and shush if necessary. Rinse and repeat (though we didn’t have to).

There are many concerns over leaving a baby to cry, and honestly, I understand where you’re coming from if you think this way. Yes, it seems unnatural to let your baby cry when everything in you wants to rescue them. Use your instinct. This doesn’t work for all babies; it really depends on temperament. K needs her space, and I knew that she was crying because she was pissed off…not because she was hurt, or hungry, or wet. If that crying had changed (and she sounded hysterical, or was gagging), I would have intervened.

Others think that checking on baby just serves to get them riled up even more. Again, this is all about the temperament of your baby. If you know that your kiddo will just get angry if you pop your head in after 5 minutes, then don’t do it. Set a longer time limit, or don’t set one at all. A video monitor might come in handy (but isn’t necessary…we don’t have one), so you’re not tempted to peek and disrupt the process.

The moral of the story? Use which method works for you.

7 thoughts on “Adventures in Sleep Training

  1. My husband and I have been going through trying to sleep train our son and it hasn’t been easy. We tried a similar method to yours, but it just didn’t seem to work. I felt like the crying just made my son more irritable all the time. Plus, he wasn’t really putting himself to sleep and when he did it took over 30 of crying-checking-crying-checking. Now, since we’ve stopped he goes to sleep on his own between 8-9 and wakes around 12 to feed and maybe around 3. Most days he’s up for the day between 7-8. Not too bad, from where we were, but I just couldn’t take the constant crying and him being irritable.

    • Every baby’s personality is SO different – and this absolutely doesn’t work for everyone. I hope you find something that works well for your little guy!

  2. We did a similar method with our daughter when she was 14 months (she’s now 19 months). She was probably ready for it sooner but I wasn’t lol and I think the moms mind set is more than half the battle! Up until then I was nursing her to sleep, which I was fine with, but we’re due with #2 in a few weeks and I needed her to learn to go to sleep without me.
    I’m glad it worked for you!

  3. Pingback: The Elusive Nap: Adventures in Nap Training | baking & babies

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s